Since there are no currently active contests, we have switched Climate CoLab to read-only mode.
Learn more at https://climatecolab.org/page/readonly.
Skip navigation

Please find below the judging results for your proposal.

Finalist Evaluation

Judges'' comments


Finalist - Do Not Advance



SUBJECT: Climate CoLab Judging Results

Proposal: Agricultural tips on radio,mobiles along with Technical prediction and solutions

Contest: Anticipating Climate Change in the Pamir Mountains

Thank you for participating in the 2015 Climate CoLab Anticipating Climate Change in the Pamir Mountains contest, and for the time you spent in creating and revising your entry.

The Judges have strongly considered your proposal in this second round of evaluation, and have chosen to not advance it as a Finalist for this contest.

We, the Judges and contest Fellows, are truly grateful for your contribution to the Climate CoLab and for your commitment to address climate change.

We encourage you to keep developing your work. Transfer it to the Proposal Workspace to re-open it, make edits, add collaborators, and even submit it into a future contest. You can do so by logging into your account, opening your proposal, selecting the Admin tab, and clicking “Move proposal”.

We hope you will stay involved in the Climate CoLab community. Please support and comment on proposals that have been named Finalists and vote for which proposal you would like to be nominated as the contest’s Popular Choice Winner.

If you have questions, please contact the Climate CoLab staff at admin@climatecolab.org

Keep up the great work. And thank you again for being a part of this mission to harness the world’s collective efforts to develop and share innovative climate change solutions.



2015 Climate CoLab Judges



[Additional comments from the Judges]


Judges' Comments
The notion of using radio to help farmers tell their stories, and framing those stories around their experience with using and modifying traditional calendars is very exciting, and has a strong participatory character. That is a key strength of the proposal. The non-profit, Cultural Survival is helping local communities develop their own radio stations to broadcast info on a broad range of topics pertinent to the population that is not available elsewhere. Such models work when there are a variety of issues being addressed by the population as they chose what primary issues are.
The project will need partnership with existing broadcasting bodies and significant training for all, including students. The feasibility of such efforts is not clear. This can turn into a project bigger than planned. There seem to be a weak participation by the farmers and others.
The proposal really lacks in the integration of scientific data, and it would be much stronger if there were more discussion of how the radio program would incorporate meteorological and climatological data and what kinds of data would be used. Another suggestion might be to reconsider the division of the radio program into and ask the experts section and a section featuring a local farmer – or at least explain how that division is consistent with the notion of integrating or bridging the two “ways of knowing”. This proposal was also a difficult to read and follow, and an improved organization would be helpful.

Semi-Finalist Evaluation

Judges'' ratings


Novelty:
Feasibility:
Impact:
Presentation:

Judges'' comments


SUBJECT: Your proposal has been selected as a Semi-Finalist!

Congratulations! Your proposal, Agricultural tips on radio and mobiles in the Anticipating Climate Change in the Pamir Mountains contest, has been selected to advance to the Semi-Finalists round.

You will be able to revise your proposal and add new collaborators if you wish, from now until the revision deadline (June 18, 11:59pm [EDT]).

Judges' feedback are posted under the "Evaluation" tab of your proposal. Please incorporate this feedback in your revisions, or your proposal may not be advanced to the Finalists round. We ask you to also summarize the changes that you made in the comment section of the Evaluation tab.

At the revision deadline, your proposal will be locked and considered in final form. The Judges will undergo another round of evaluation to ensure that Semi-Finalist proposals have addressed the feedback given, and select which proposals will continue to the Finalists round. Finalists are eligible for the contest’s Judges Choice award, as well as for public voting to select the contest’s Popular Choice award.

Thank you for your great work and again, congratulations!



Contest Judges

Judges' Feedback:

Engaging the community first to find who the community deems as experts in the type of knowledge the community feels it needs, would make this a good proposal. A radio program may or may not generate interest if the questions and the dialogue are not generated by the community. There are many examples of participatory radio problem solving programs through Cultural Survival, radio.

The concept of using radio as a readily accessible media for communicating with farmers and others in an interactive manner, especially involving students, is attractive. The use of World Bank Climate Data as a resource is a practical approach, and could be valuable provided the data is translated into representations that are familiar to the local populations. The proposal does not address, at least adequately, the issues of the resources that the farmers currently use, so that these can be improved by including climate change and related factors.

11comments
Share conversation: Share via:

Venkatesh R

Jun 6, 2015
01:18

Member


1 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
Hi, Thanks for your feedback and questions. 1)It is important to form a community, if we can use the students, the better as they have the ease of understanding the technology and they will act as an interface with the local community and they will understand the requirement of their people better as they have a cultural benefits. This community should feel free in discussing about the issues and can give their suggestion as well, so here we need to use the researchers who are already working with them as they have developed a good rapport with these peoples. 2)We can use the https://www.climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/-/plans/contestId/1301102/phaseId/1306618/planId/1313804 as a reference to the resource to be used or We need to collect the weather prediction report from the climate data, Soil analysis based on weather prediction (fertility changes with flood), change in mountain heights due nature catastrophic and expert judgment and fine tune the analysis. The expert judgment data will contain the information from the community, researchers working with them based on their past predictions they need to give the information,Along with the above information we can use the predicted/forecast climate information as mentioned to provide information to the farmers. So we can build a calendar with this feedback as a delta correction in terms of days, so the farmers will understand it better as the calendar is better interface to make them understand. As per my understanding currently the farmers prediction based on the calendar is not working, their judgement on the season gets changed by 15 or 20 days, this days can help in choosing an alternative crop or if possible mixed agriculture.Probably in the current generation, the prediction is not accurate as there has been a change in the climate and natural calamities which has not been considered in the calendar. This changes is introduced some where but when we consider earth as an system, a change in one place will trigger a big change in another place so it is important to use the scientific data along with the experts feedback to produce a delta factor which helps in fine tune the prediction. Based on taking the recordings for few years we can re build a stable calendar and share with the community. please let me know if i have answered your question. Can some one elaborate the statement "The proposal does not address, at least adequately, the issues of the resources that the farmers currently use" I am not getting the statement "issues of the resources that the farmers currently use" is it about the calendar or how the agriculture is being conducted in this region? Thanks Venkatesh

Venkatesh R

Jun 6, 2015
04:09

Member


2 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
When i say about the community, it is of two type. 1) The Farmers Community along with the students 2) The Scientific Community. The scientific community is a complex group, which comprises scientist and data analysis from various department.This community can be established at an university collaboration level by using a secure site for the discussion and can have a social media, which can be accessed by the students and program presenter. This community should have scientist who does research in various segments, geological change, climate change, natural catastrophe effect, fauna and flora changes. The season change is so complex that all these interactions are needed to have a better output. These communities can't be formed in a day or so, it will take time, but it will give worthy results when it gets implemented.These communities not only helps to solve or address the Pamir's challenge, this is for a broader perspective, for the issues we will be facing in the future.

Venkatesh R

Jun 7, 2015
03:40

Member


3 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
we need to share the history of the calendar, so that the younger generation understands bit, so a gen introduction program on the mapping will help them to get up to the speed, then we can introduce the complex section of addressing the issue through the questionnaire, once the people gets up to the speed, probably the scientific team can make an approx delta value that can be incorporated in the calendar as mention in previous comments.

Catalina Oaida

Jun 10, 2015
09:53

Fellow


4 |
Share via:
Dear Venkatesh, Thank you for responding to the judges' feedback and working on improving the proposal. I believe the comment by the judges, "The proposal does not address, at least adequately, the issues of the resources that the farmers currently use" is likely referring to the fact that the proposal does not address how this method would also deal with anticipating climate change in the region. The proposal call states: "The goal of this contest is to find ways to use both traditional and scientific knowledge to adapt the calendars and anticipate the effects of climate change." While your proposal seems to focus on adapting and maintaining traditional calendars and knowledge (via radio programs), which is important, it does not (at least directly) address how the locals would understand and adapt to effects from climate change. Hope this helps. -catalina Climate Co-Lab Fellow

Venkatesh R

Jun 11, 2015
07:24

Member


5 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
Hi, There are two parts in this radio program: Part 1 1)Session on the Calendar so the generation gap in the understanding of the calendar gets addressed. So youngsters participates with enthusiasm Part 2 2)The expert interview, where the farmer with in the community will predict, answers the questions to the other farmers. 3)Is the use of technology to predict and fine tune the prediction along with the expert judgement. The use of technology will be complex as it leads to the interaction between various team to get the exact output. As a change in climate, will change water vapor contents, number of earth worms may also change,and because of natural calamities there may be a shift in the altitude of the mountains, so in directly the wind flow as well changes. So we need to measure all these and the interaction between experts in the field is a must. Directing the locals with Technology team and Expert Judgement Team So the representative from the technology side along with the expert prediction, they need to answer and guide the other farmers.This guidance can be given through the radio. For the initial days, these may be like spoon feeding where the prediction needs to be done at least 2 weeks ahead of the season, with weather prediction and in turn soil erosion / fertility needs to be analyzed, so that farmers can make the preparation. Where as the expert judges based on their experience, and the amount of sun light falling on the region at a given time. Making the locals to take ownership: Going forward the technology team, needs to develop a delta correction value, based on the region's location such as availability of water, air temp, mountain heights, soil fertility etc. so that going forward prediction becomes more accurate and the farmers can take the ownership of the same. Probably the need to do this 4 times in a year, so that can for an accurate formula As a start up, the soil fertility analysis and air temperature measuring team can be formed as technical team.We can use,research students for this analysis so they get an opportunity to learn if they are within this region or nearby country it would be better as they can interact with the local people, and going forward based on the accuracy of prediction we can add other teams that can predict the wind speed in the region, if there is a change etc. The students will work with the villagers and the local technical team in collecting sample data such as soil, wind speed measurement, how the air temperature is varying, and the data on fauna and flora and their population etc, if we can set this as part of the education curriculum it would be better /or we can give some credit points to keep them motivated. Please let me know, if any further clarification is needed. Thanks Venkatesh

Morgan Ruelle

Jun 12, 2015
04:31

Fellow


6 |
Share via:
Hi Venkatesh, Thanks for all of your work trying to address the judges' questions! Please make sure that you incorporate these ideas very clearly into your proposal. I can tell you are someone who appreciates the complexity of systems, so you mention how everything is interrelated, but sometimes we need to identify the most important elements so that the reader doesn't get lost. At this stage, I think you need to clarify your proposal by focusing key elements. Although I am not entirely clear as to what the judges meant by 'resources', I think that the traditional calendar of the human body is the most important local resource. This was an amazing calendar because it was not 'fixed' in terms of months or years that are a specific number of days, but rather a flexible calendar based on ecological cues that made it easier for farmers to respond to variable climate. If the hisobdon (keeper of time) observed a certain set of cues, s/he would instruct the villagers to begin counting on their bodies. After that, each villager would know how to apply the counting in their own context. For example, one farmer might plant wheat when they reached the knee, but another, higher up in the valley, might wait until the thigh. This same flexibility is what we need for climate change, because it's not just a simple 'shift' of seasons earlier or later, it's an increase in the degree that weather patterns vary - both earlier and later - from year to year. Your proposal is clear that students will collect new ecological data, and discuss their data with elders, who have knowledge from accumulated experience as well as linkages to past generations. It is also clear that discussing such knowledge on the radio is a good way to explore possible actions for climate change adaptation. I am still hoping you can be more specific about what you want the students to investigate, or else how they will determine which components of the ecosystem are the most important to investigate. Could this be the goal of your first radio shows, to interview elders about the most useful ecological cues? After that, the students could collect data and compare their observations to elders' knowledge, in order for communities to begin discussing changes and identifying the most reliable cues. If the students could learn to compare their observations to global climate data, that would be great too! But you need to start with basic questions to understand all factors, and then focus in on the most important factors. I hope that helps! Please read through and make sure that everything is clearly explained with a strong logical flow. Also, try to eliminate the less important details - sometimes those can do more harm than good because they distract us from your main points. All the best, Morgan

Venkatesh R

Jun 12, 2015
11:13

Member


7 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
Hi, I have updated the proposal description section please check. Thanks Venkatesh

Venkatesh R

Jun 14, 2015
08:46

Member


8 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
Apart from the points i have mentioned in the proposal and the blog links i have shared, i want to share an important point on pastorals and habitual fuel consumption in these regions. We need to clear the unwanted and poisonous grasses as per this research the pastoral gets affected due to some grasses http://www.researchgate.net/profile/S_Breckle/publication/261596535_Effects_of_Grazing_on_Biodiversity_Productivity_and_Soil_Erosion_of_Alpine_Pastures_in_Tajik_Mountains/links/0c960534c3e6e3ed4f000000.pdf they can remove the soil nutrients at a faster rate and can turn into barren lands. Some research shows that Mycorrhizal Fungi helps in growing plants but, we need to check if its feasibile for every crops, if mixed farming can be done along with Mycorrhizal Fungi will provide results in pamir regions and make the land fertile ? a must watch documentary film on plants what plants talk about ? Alternate thermal insulation: As per MRD-Journal research on pamir's fuel consumption the main fuel consumption in this area are more for thermal insulation rather than cooking so switch to alternate powers it will reduce the woods and grasses consumption as well, check the feasibility of this idea in pamir https://winter2015.unhcrideas.org/Page/ViewIdea?ideaid=3797 probably Catalina Oaida can comment on this if such a thermal insulation can help this region. More over if they can switch to solar and wind energy it can save a lot of vegetation and soil erosion.

Venkatesh R

Jun 14, 2015
09:49

Member


9 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
Hi, Apart from the points i have mentioned in the proposal and the blog links i have shared, i want to share few important points on pastorals and habitual fuel consumption in these regions. Which shouldn't get ignored or missed out. We need to clear the unwanted and poisonous grasses as per this research the pastoral gets affected due to some grasses http://www.researchgate.net/profile/S_Breckle/publication/261596535_Effects_of_Grazing_on_Biodiversity_Productivity_and_Soil_Erosion_of_Alpine_Pastures_in_Tajik_Mountains/links/0c960534c3e6e3ed4f000000.pdf they can remove the soil nutrients at a faster rate and can turn into barren lands. Some research shows that Mycorrhizal Fungi helps in growing plants but, we need to check its feasibility for crops and if Nitrogen fixation is possible? or does it help pamir soil in any way ?, Effect on Nitrogen cycle in pamir region http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Cyrus_Samimi/publication/51482531_Human_and_climate_impact_on_N_natural_abundance_of_plants_and_soils_in_high-mountain_ecosystems_a_short_review_and_two_examples_from_the_Eastern_Pamirs_and_Mt._Kilimanjaro/links/53e89c480cf21cc29fdc785a.pdf if mixed farming along with Mycorrhizal Fungi will provide results in pamir regions and make the land fertile ? a must watch documentary film on plants what plants talk about ? Alternate thermal insulation: As per MRD-Journal research on pamirs fuel consumption the main fuel consumption in this area are more for thermal insulation rather than cooking so switch to alternate powers it will reduce the woods and grasses consumption as well, check the feasibility of idea http://winter2015.unhcrideas.org/Page/ViewIdea?ideaid=3797 probably Catalina Oaida and Anne Nolin can comment on this, as this is their specialization, if such a thermal insulation can help this region. we can ask the people to move to this type of houses at least for the new ones and its not going to cost them much.More over if they can switch to solar and wind energy it can save a lot of vegetation and soil erosion. In Recent years there has been a change in the life style of the people, so it is a must that we need to use these changes as well in the calendar as a shift/ correction value. Though the calendar has considered the season,altitude and sun light etc, the other side of detrimental effects has not been considered for e.g the poison grasses and their consumption by cattle and the change of people's life style by consumption of energy for thermal insulation has not been covered. These will have an effect on the calendar correction as well, which cannot be ignored. Probably the calendar can be iterated over a period of time with some adjustment values, in the mean time i feel we can develop an integrated agriculture tips comprising technology and experts advice. I have updated a lot of information in the main proposal and in the related blog content. Please ensure its been read thoroughly. Thanks Venkatesh

Venkatesh R

Jun 15, 2015
02:59

Member


10 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
Conclusion of updated proposal: In Recent years there has been a change in the life style of the people, so it is a must that we need to use these changes as well in the calendar as a shift/ correction value. Though the calendar has considered the season,altitude and sun light etc, the other side of detrimental effects has not been considered for e.g the poison grasses and their consumption by cattle and the change of people's life style by consumption of energy for thermal insulation has not been covered. These will have an effect on the calendar correction as well, which cannot be ignored. Probably the calendar can be iterated over a period of time with some adjustment values, in the mean time i feel we can develop an integrated agriculture tips comprising technology and experts advice. Action on priority for Radio broadcasting team: Please see the complete proposal, for the Radio program details and interaction between various teams. A lot of links has been shared as i didn't have enough space to share the details so please go through the entire blog as well. Things to be researched / Action on priority for technical team: http://vramanu.blogspot.in/2015/06/conclusion.html Thanks Venkatesh

Venkatesh R

Jun 18, 2015
07:44

Member


11 |
Share via:
Proposal
creator
conclusion of proposal cont... Sections updated in proposal 1)Summary 2)Who will take these actions? 3)What are the proposal’s costs? point 6 to 12 4)References -> Logical Flow diagram Team Structure http://vramanu.blogspot.in/2015/06/team-composition.html Answer to Morgan's question : Technical tips and samples to be collected / places where students needs to interact with technical team has been listed out in the blog http://vramanu.blogspot.in/2015/06/conclusion.html The priority one being the Soil Sample, and about 16 points been listed out, i feel fellow team has more experience and knows the pamir mountains better than me, so they can revisit these points and can re-order the priorities. Few of the points needs feasibility study so please go through these, this information is for prediction and guiding the farmers ahead,so the output of these research should be given as agricultural tips in otherwords give a simplified message to the farmers in terms of crop names(based on amount of rainfall predicted, earthworm prediction), amount of fertilizers (based on N2 samples,weed presence in area/valley, feasibility of earthworm fertility enhancement for the valley),grazing strategy (feasibility of algae fodder in the valley),alternate thermal insulation (based on feasibility dung cake/algae frame based houses and switching to alternate energy source). Thanks Venkatesh